It starts innocently. A large customer pays later than usual, a supplier suddenly demands advance payment, and the cash flow line is regularly strained at the end of the month. Each of these points has its own explanation, and taken individually they are not dramatic. Taken together, they mark the shift in the role of management: from entrepreneurial freedom to a situation of obligations with personal liability.
The transition is fluid; the legal consequences are not. Whoever misses the moment when a tense situation becomes a requirement to file a claim is liable with their personal assets. Whoever recognizes it usually still has some leeway to act that they would not have had later on.
clience.legal is a digital business law firm for entrepreneurs. We support managing directors in crisis situations while keeping the restructuring of the company and the protection against personal liability in mind. This article shows the insolvency law thresholds, the key indicators that can be used to assess the situation, and the actions that are due at what point.
The most important information at a glance
- Section 1 of the StaRUG requires ongoing monitoring: The management must recognize developments that could endanger the company’s survival, take countermeasures, and inform the supervisory bodies.
- There are three thresholds to be considered: threatened insolvency with a forecast period of 24 months, insolvency and over-indebtedness with a forecast period of 12 months.
- Application deadlines are maximum deadlines: three weeks for insolvency, six weeks for over-indebtedness, only in the case of serious restructuring efforts.
- Payments are dangerous: Upon entering the stage of insolvency, payments release the reimbursement obligation under § 15b InsO.
- Threatening insolvency opens up options: At this stage, rehabilitation instruments are available that can still avoid the requirement to submit an application.
- The instrument is liquidity planning: Without a rolling preview, there is no proof that the monitoring obligation has been fulfilled.
What § 1 StaRUG specifically requires
The provision applies to the managers of limited liability companies and requires them to continuously monitor developments that could endanger the continued existence of the company. If such developments are identified, appropriate countermeasures must be taken and the bodies appointed to monitor the situation must be informed immediately.
Three points are regularly overlooked here. First, the obligation applies on a permanent basis and not only in times of crisis. Second, it requires not only recognition but also action and reporting. Third, it requires a system that fits the company. In an operation with twenty employees, a manageable level of planning is sufficient as long as it is regularly maintained and documented.
The sanction does not result from the STAUR itself, but from general organizational liability. Anyone who fails to monitor and thereby causes damage is liable under § 43, paragraph 2, of the GmbHG. Practically relevant is the evidence aspect: In the subsequent proceedings, the question is asked as to when the development was recognizable. Without documented planning, the answer falls to the detriment of the management. More on this under crisis early detection under the StaRUG.
Why the transition is so often overlooked
In retrospect, the timing usually seems clear. In the situation itself, it is not, and there are understandable reasons for that.
The first is explainability. Every single development has a cause that sounds plausible: a delayed project, a customer with their own payment problems, a seasonal glitch. As long as every deviation can be explained, there is no pressure to act. Only the sum adds up to the picture, and only the sum shows who is putting the numbers together.
The second reason is attention. In times of stress, operational business takes up all of the management’s time. It is then that planning is less frequently maintained, even though it would be needed more urgently. This effect is so widespread that it appears regularly in reports.
The third reason is psychological. Those who have built their own company evaluate opportunities more optimistically than an outsider. Of course, the expected large order is factored into the planning, but its absence is not taken into account. Planning with a deliberately pessimistic scenario costs little time and corrects this very distortion.
The three thresholds
Impending illiquidity
It is considered when the company is not expected to be able to meet its existing payment obligations at the time they fall due. The forecast period is usually 24 months. This threshold does not trigger an application obligation, but an entitlement to apply, and it is the access to the Sanierungsinstrumenten des StaRUG. That is precisely why it is the most important threshold: Those who recognize it have options.
Illiquidity
It intervenes when the company is no longer able to meet its payment obligations. The practice operates with a liquidity balance over a period of three weeks. A deficit of less than ten percent is regularly still considered a temporary payment bottleneck, provided it is foreseeable that the gap will be closed. If the gap exceeds this or persists, insolvency must be assumed. From this point on, the three-week application deadline begins.
Over-indebtedness
Overindebtedness exists when the assets no longer cover the existing liabilities and the continuation of the business in the next twelve months is not predominantly likely. The continuation forecast thus determines the outcome, and it is a matter of planning, not of the balance sheet. If it is positive, despite the calculated overindebtedness, no grounds for insolvency exist. The application deadline is six weeks.
Ten early warning indicators
The insolvency thresholds are legal concepts. In everyday life, developments are revealed earlier, namely through signals that can be observed with little effort.
- Current account line permanently strained: When the line no longer has breathing capacity but becomes a permanent financing source, there is no buffer against disruptions.
- Extended payment deadlines for suppliers: If invoices are paid later than intended, suppliers finance the operation. This becomes noticeable and changes their behavior.
- Switching to prepayment: If a supplier requires advance payment or security, he has already assessed your creditworthiness.
- Reduced limits of the credit insurer: A cut has an immediate effect on the readiness of all connected suppliers to deliver, and often comes without prior warning.
- Applications for deferral of payment at the tax office or health insurance company: A clear signal that is also relevant to liability issues, because social security contributions must be paid first and foremost.
- Increasing levels of indebtedness in the lending sector: The number of transactions in the second and third warning stages is a more precise indicator than the account balance.
- Declining order intake with stable sales: Sales reflect the past, order intake the next few months.
- Incurred or threatened credit obligations: Commitments are often reviewed quarterly. Any foreseeable violation should be discussed with the bank before the deadline.
- Dependence on individual customers: If a customer exceeds a significant percentage of sales, their payment behavior is directly linked to your liquidity risk.
- Delayed accounting: If the figures are only available weeks later, monitoring is practically impossible. This point is regularly used against the management in liability cases.
For the purposes of liability assessment, the distinction between the three thresholds is therefore so important because it changes the role of the management. Before reaching a threshold, entrepreneurial discretion exists, which also covers risky decisions, as long as they were made on the basis of adequate information. Once insolvency maturity is reached, there is no longer such discretion, because mandatory obligations with their own deadlines and a payment ban then take effect. Anyone who fails to notice this change continues to act according to entrepreneurial logic in an area where it no longer applies legally.
The instrument: rolling liquidity planning
To fulfill the monitoring obligation, no elaborate system is needed. A thirteen-week, weekly preview that is continuously updated has proven to be effective, supplemented by a twelve- to twenty-four-month monthly plan for longer-term consideration.
Three characteristics are crucial. The planning must be complete, which means that it must include taxes, social contributions, refunds and special payments. It must be regularly compared with reality so that deviations become visible. And it must be documented because in an emergency it is your proof of compliance.
In addition, there are defined thresholds: at what level of underperformance will escalation be triggered, who will be informed, and what action will be taken. This advance determination is valuable because it prevents discussions about whether to escalate in a tense situation. How to implement this in the company is described below. Holistic corporate stabilization.
An indication of the significance of the data: Individual indicators do not provide much information. The picture becomes meaningful when several indicators point in the same direction simultaneously and the trend continues over several weeks. Therefore, it is useful to record the values once a week in the same overview and to observe the trend instead of the cut-off date. A table with ten rows is sufficient; what is crucial is the regularity.
What to do at what threshold
In the event of noticeable tension without reaching a threshold: Plan to intensify the situation, initiate countermeasures, inform shareholders and, if necessary, the advisory board. This notification is not a courtesy; it is part of the duty under § 1 StaRUG.
In the event of threatened insolvency: examination of the restructuring options, ranging from negotiations with creditors to the financing components of the Restructuring Framework of the StaRUG. In this phase, the scope for action is greatest because no application obligation exists yet. Among the options under Restructuring and financing of companies in crisis.
In the event of insolvency or overindebtedness: The application period has expired. In parallel, the payment ban of § 15b InsO applies; payments that are compatible with the diligence of a proper business manager remain permissible. This distinction is delicate and should not be made without consultation. Social contributions and taxes retain their own system of procedures. For details, see below. Bankruptcy advice for entrepreneurs and the typical errors under liability pitfalls in a corporate crisis.
Who besides you noticed the crisis?
Management is rarely the first to recognize an emerging trend. Several stakeholders have their own early warning systems, and their behavior further changes the situation.
- Credit insurers: They continuously assess vendor ratings and reduce limits as soon as key metrics deteriorate. This reduction affects several suppliers simultaneously and can make procuring difficult within days.
- Banks: Account movements, delinquents, and the depletion of the line are evaluated. A conversation that you seek on your own is different from one that is invited to.
- Suppliers: The changed payment behavior first becomes noticeable in the accounting of the other party. The reaction is usually advance payment or a shortening of the deadlines.
- Tax advisors: They are obliged to point out possible reasons for insolvency if they have relevant evidence to support this.
- Employees: Delayed payments, cancelled investments and rumors lead to attrition, mostly first among those who provide the services.
This leads to a practical recommendation: Those who recognize the development themselves and communicate actively retain the authority to interpret it. Those who wait, later negotiate with those who have already formed an opinion.
Five mistakes in the early phase
- The accounting follows reality, so the situation becomes visible only with delay.
- Shareholders are only informed when a decision is imminent, rather than when the development is detected.
- Payments are made on a case-by-case basis, rather than according to legal requirements, which leads to the obligation to reimburse after insolvency has arisen.
- The application deadline is understood as a processing period, although it is a maximum deadline for serious renovation efforts.
- One waits for a single event, such as an expected large order, without having alternative planning in place in case it fails to materialize.
Each of these points can be set aside beforehand; in the crisis itself, it is hardly possible to do so anymore. This is precisely the value of preparation. To deepen our explanations regarding the liability side, we have prepared the following documents: personal liability in GmbH and UG and to the current developments in managing directors’ liability.
Related: Legal prevention in the company and Liability check for managers.
Send us a brief description of the situation: liquidity forecast, balance of liabilities, open negotiations with banks or creditors, and the question that concerns you most. We will determine where you stand in terms of insolvency law, which deadlines are running out, and what action options are open. To do this, arrange an appointment. free initial consultation from 15 to 20 minutes. Our professional framework consists of our advice on Compliance and managing director liability and the ongoing accompaniment as external legal department.
FAQs
What does § 1 StaRUG require from the management?
Limited liability companies’ managers must continuously monitor developments that could endanger the company’s continued existence. If such developments are identified, appropriate countermeasures must be taken and the supervisory bodies must be informed immediately. The obligation exists permanently and not only in times of crisis. The scope and design depend on the size and complexity of the company.
When is imminent insolvency imminent?
If the company is expected not to be able to meet existing payment obligations when due. The forecast period is usually 24 months. This threshold does not constitute an obligation to apply, but rather a right to apply, and it opens access to the Sanierungsinstrumenten des StaRUG. For practice, it is the most important threshold because this is the phase in which the scope for action is greatest.
How is insolvency determined?
A liquidity balance sheet, in which current liabilities are compared to available funds, usually over a period of three weeks. A deficit of less than ten percent is regularly treated as a temporary payment bottleneck, if it is foreseeable that the gap will be closed. If the gap exceeds this or persists, insolvency must be assumed. The demarcation is challenging in individual cases and should not be undertaken without professional guidance.
What exactly does overindebtedness mean?
The assets no longer cover the existing liabilities, and the continuation of the company is not highly likely in the next twelve months. The decisive factor is the continuation forecast, which must be based on reliable planning. If it turns out positive, despite the calculated over-indebtedness, there is no ground for insolvency. The application deadline is six weeks for over-indebtedness.
How long must I wait to file for insolvency?
The application must be submitted without any culpable delay, no later than three weeks after the insolvency has occurred and within six weeks after the overindebtedness has occurred. These timeframes are maximum deadlines and may only be used as long as serious and promising recovery efforts are underway. If the recovery is demonstrably hopeless, action must be taken immediately. Exceeding the deadline without making any efforts constitutes a breach of duty.
Can I still pay bills during the crisis?
Upon entering insolvency proceedings, the payment ban set out in § 15b InsO applies. Payments that are compatible with the diligence of an ordinary business manager remain permissible, such as those intended to preserve the chance of a restructuring. Banned payments trigger a duty to reimburse the company. Since the distinction in individual cases is difficult to determine, it should not be made without consultation once the threshold is reached.
Which key figures should I monitor continuously?
A thirteen-week forecast of liquidity is useful, supplemented by a twelve- to twenty-four-month monthly plan. In addition, operational indicators such as order intake, utilization of the credit line, the number of transactions at higher levels, the limits of the credit insurer, and the delay in accounting are helpful. More important than the selection is regularity and documentation.
What is the restructuring framework under the StaRUG?
A court-supervised procedure that is available in cases of threatened insolvency and can enable a restructuring without insolvency proceedings. At its core is a restructuring plan that, under certain conditions, can also be effective against the will of individual creditor groups. The procedure requires reliable planning and careful preparation. It is no longer open once insolvency or overindebtedness has occurred.
Will a D-and-O insurance policy protect me during the crisis?
It can cover property damage caused by breaches of duty, but there are limits. Intentional breaches of duty are regularly excluded, as are fines and penalties. Also, check how claims from the company itself are handled; these are the main focus of insolvency proceedings. Insurance does not replace timely response.
When is it worth hiring a lawyer in case of tight liquidity?
As soon as several early warning indicators appear simultaneously, it is worth having a conversation. We determine where you stand in terms of insolvency law, whether and what deadlines are in effect, and which payments are still permissible. At the same time, we examine the restructuring options that remain open during the phase of imminent insolvency. The early stage is crucial because the scope for action narrows with each week and the personal liability increases with it.